Thank you and everyone else for your clarifications and discussion! We are going to approve Crowley ships for this round (assuming the other characters in the ship qualify for femslashex as well, of course). Given Crowley's presentation at various points in the show, there's a strong argument that ships including him and other characters could be read as femslash-adjacent. (Because Crowley is somewhat of an edge case, I'd like to clarify that we're considering the characters he's shipped with as well, and won't be approving any ships such as Aziraphale/Crowley where the other party has an exclusively masculine presentation/etc.)

One note on some of the discussion below - we don't consider fandom presence and trends in our approval or rejection of tags, just canonical gender and/or presentation (and occasionally Word of God as supplementary information if canon is vague).

Thanks again for the discussion, all of you were very helpful! We will be opening a discussion at the end of the round regarding our current ship and character eligibility if anyone would like to make a case for changing the rules as they stand now, so please hold onto your comments on that until after the round concludes.