I nominated under Power Rangers (TV):
Lily Chilman/Trini Kwan
Kimberly Hart/Trini Kwan

AO3 suggests changing them to:
Lily Chilman/Trini
Kimberly Hart/Trini

Those tags without her last name are incorrect for the show continuity.

The reboot movie doesn't say Trini's last name, so the AO3 mods stripped Kwan from all the TV show tags despite that being her canonical last name for 25 years and the two versions of the character having almost nothing in common.

Thanks for the heads up! We'll make sure we keep them as nominated

Hey mod, would you be at all willing to consider dividing The Lord of the Rings into books and movies, rather than All Media Types? There are some Tolkien fans (including me) who have strong preferences for one vs. the other.

Hi, we can definitely discuss it! Can you lay out the canon differences and divergences that might justify the split, my memory of the movie promo at the time is that the movies were intended to reasonably faithfully follow the books but I've never been a close reader of the books so there might be more differences than I'm aware of. It would be particularly helpful to know if it's comparable to something like Game of Thrones or another franchise that we already split (or don't split).

If other Tolkien nominators passing by wish to chime in, please feel free. It's handled a bit differently to the other large fandoms, but those discussions largely pre-date the current mods so it would probably be best to review the whole fandom instead of just Lord of the Rings (if we were to make any changes) to make sure we're across all the relevant info.

Psst, did you mean to delete a comment or did something go awry? I got a comment notification, if it's gone astray without you intending it to let me know and I can copy your comment over from my email if you need it. I'll screen this so you can reply privately if you want.

So I've been trying to edit my noms as described in the rules.

I tried to nominate Sailor Moon Crystal instead the tag I'm currently using for my Sailor Moon ships, but the form page said that Sailor Moon Crystal is a freeform tag and couldn't be used that way.

I also tried to tag my ships for Star Wars Legends: Knights of the Old Republic under the Star Wars - All Media Types and the form page said nope that to as well.

I have also edited my mass effect noms accordingly as well to the best of my ability.

Edited 2018-07-26 12:18 am (UTC)

We can fix things on our end, too, since it sounds like AO3 is throwing a fit at you. Would you mind sharing your nominated ships? You can do it in a comment here or in a PM to me

In Once Upon a Time

Red Riding/Snow White

Hi there, are you wanting to nominate that pairing or is there another issue with it? Nominations need to be submitted via AO3 here. If you don't have an AO3 account, you'll need one to nominate and sign-up. We can assist with invitations to jump the queue for a new account, shoot us an email at femslashexmod@gmail.com if you need one.

I nominated Kitty Pryde/Rogue and Wanda Maximoff/Rogue under X-Men Evolution, but I think they got moved to Marvel 616? :'D

Oops, sorry about that! They must have wandered and been caught up in some other 616 corrections. They should be fixed now.

Found a duplicate, under ボールルームへようこそ | Ballroom e Youkoso:

Akagi Mako/Hanaoka Shizuku
Hanaoka Shizuku/Akagi Mako

Thank you!

Spotted a duplicate fandom: Sailor Moon (90s anime) is under Anime & Manga while Sailor Moon (Anime 1992) is under Uncategorized Fandoms.

Also, Aigis/Arisato Minako, Arisato Minako/Yamagishi Fuuka, and Takeba Yukari/Yamagishi Fuuka have wandered over to Persona 4 from Persona 3.

Thank you!

Quick update on Persona: Takeba Yukari/Yamagishi Fuuka should be correctly associated and no longer in Persona 4. It's been flagged that we should consider using Female Persona 3 Protagonist instead of Arisato Minako.

If you are a Persona 3 fan (and didn't only notice the wandering because you're in Persona 4), and have an opinion please feel free to jump in on the thread below this one to discuss it if you want.

Persona 4
Aigis/Arisato Minako
Arisato Minako/Yamagishi Fuuka
Takeba Yukari/Yamagishi Fuuka

Those are all Persona 3 ships that have wandered into Persona 4. Also, "Arisato Minako" is a fan nickname for the female protagonist of Persona 3, it isn't canon.

http://megamitensei.wikia.com/wiki/Female_Protagonist_(Persona_3_Portable)

Is it possible to get Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga) renamed to Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Crystal & Manga)? The Anime & Manga version is for 90s anime, Crystal, and the manga, but you have the 90s version separated out.

I've reassociated those ships with Persona 3, thanks! I'll bring up renaming the Persona 3 protagonist with my comod.

Would it be better to combine the anime under the Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga) tag? Or is renaming our current tag to Crystal & Manga better? I'm not familiar with the fandom, so I'm open to input.

Hi, it is me again!

Small question: If we are doing the Marvel Cinematic Universe as MCU in the nominations, then would the DC Cinematic Universe be DCU or DCCU for nominations?

Edited 2018-07-26 09:00 pm (UTC)

We're using DC Cinematic Universe, no abbreviation, to differentiate from our tag for DC comics, DCU

Some of my ships are in "Unassociated Characters & Relationships":

These were nominated under "Buffy the Vampire Slayer & Related Fandoms" (under TV)
Buffy Summers/Kendra Young
Satsu/Buffy Summers
Tara Maclay/Buffy Summers

These were nominated under "Star Wars - All Media Types"
Jyn Erso/Ahsoka Tano
Q'ira/Ahsoka Tano

And I'm not the original nominator, but Aya | Amunet (Assassin's Creed)/Cleopatra VII of Egypt isn't a "Xena: Warrior Princess" (under TV) pairing. It could be an Assassin's Creed ship, a crossover with the historical character, or a crossover with the Xena character.

The unassociated ships should all be in the correct places now. Thanks for the heads up about the crossover! We'll ask the nominator for more information before we edit and move it to make sure we have the correct Cleopatra, so it may hang around a little while longer but I have made a note.

I nominated some pairings under Sailor Moon (Anime 1992) and someone came along after me and nominated Sailor Moon (90s anime). These fandoms can be merged since they're the same thing; AO3 just doesn't have a canonical fandom tag for it. (Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga) is the generic - thank you for letting us split SM!!.)

Edited 2018-07-27 05:32 pm (UTC)

We're using the following splits/combos now, if you disagree with anything let us know?
Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Manga/Crystal)
Sailor Moon (1992 Anime)
Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Live Action TV)

Both exisiting anime tags have been combined and the pairings moved, but if anything you nominated isn't in 1992 Anime let me know and I'll chase it down for you :)

All of the old-continuity Star Treks together under "Star Trek: Classic Timeline (All Series)," AOS under "Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies)‎"

Just to check: This does include Star Trek: Discovery under "Star Trek: Classic Timeline (All Series)", right? Since that show takes place between Enterprise and the original series (TOS) and isn't in a different timeline.

Would this also mean that a ship between a woman who only appears in the AOS movies (e.g. Jaylah or Commodore Paris) and one who only appears in the classic timeline (e.g. T'Pol or Philippa Georgiou or Emony Dax) would count as a crossover ship? Or, since it's possible to theorize that those characters exist in both versions of the Star Trek universe, would we nominate them as if they existed in the timeline we want?

In other words, if I want to nominate Jaylah (who only appears in the AOS movie Star Trek Beyond) with Sylvia Tilly (who only appears in the prime-timeline series Star Trek Discovery), and I wanted it set in the Discovery/prime timeline setting, would I submit it as:

Crossovers --> Jaylah (Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies))/Sylvia Tilly (Star Trek: Classic Timeline (All Series))

or

Star Trek: Classic Timeline (All Series) --> Jaylah/Sylvia Tilly

??

(I mention this because a lot of people ship Commodore Paris (Shohreh Aghdashloo) from Beyond with Philippa Georgiou from Discovery. Almost always set in the Discovery universe, though you *could* write Georgiou in the AOS setting, I suppose.)

Third question: With Star Trek, do Mirror Universe characters just get nominated under their relevant usual canon? (Intendent Kira or Emperor Georgiou as characters under ST: Classic Timeline?) This seems to be the case! Solved :-)

Edited 2018-07-28 06:23 am (UTC)

Good question! Yes, we will be going by the word of god confirmation that Discovery is set in the Prime universe, so they will be folded under Classic.

So yes, Jaylah/Tilly or similar pairings become crossovers. Having said that, yes I think you can definitely make a case for nominating their alternates if you're either specifically interested in or just open to speculative characterisation/backstory changes. Use tags like AOS Philippa, or Prime Jaylah. That falls comfortably under the unnamed but inferrable character rule in my opinion. It is also in line with the way we use Mirror [Character] tags for mirror versions where they don't have a specific title like Emperor to distinguish them from their Prime version, or if they're unnamed but inferred.

So yes, I realise you've already answered yourself but in case anyone passing by was confused, Mirror goes under Classic as Prime/Mirror characters canonically meet. At this stage, I would say that Mirror characters should probably only go under Classic (eg. Mirror Jaylah would also be Classic, if someone wants to take the logical leap further that if Jaylah is in Prime/Classic then she's probably also in Mirror.) I'm not aware of any tie-in or word of god confirmations saying AOS has its own version of the mirror verse - though there could well be something I've not seen. Or maybe Prime characters are the only ones who tend to blunder around across realities opening up cracks, heh. If there is reason to believe there is an AOS version of Mirror, we may need to think about how to preface any nominations for AOS and Mirror characters to indicate which version of Mirror is meant, if they come up at all.

Edit: oh, and it's up to you and we may or may not tweak them as we approve them, but if you want to save yourself some typing and keep your Star Trek crossover tags more readable feel free to use shorthand like Star Trek AOS or Star Trek Classic or Star Trek DISCO etc if you prefer. Our fandom tags are longer, but crossovers don't need a group fandom indication just for the sake of it unless using an umbrella name like Classic for any Mirror characters simplifies things too.

Edited 2018-07-28 09:33 am (UTC)

the sleepless domain nominations "Kokoro/Undine Wells/Tessa Quinn" and "Kokoro/Undine Wells" should probably be updated since kokoro's last name (aichi) just got revealed in a recent page; the ao3 tags were probably "canonized" by wranglers way before this update.

Thanks for the heads up! Is Kokoro likely to be confused with another character without the last name included? We will probably stick with the canonical if there's no issues likely to arise from leaving the last name off, as it's more work to tweak existing tags than to edit them before they're approved. But definitely let us know if it causes issues beyond being technically incomplete, and we can update.